Was Warren Buffett's success predictable?

The mainstream financial media is built around having experts appear on screen to give the comforting impression that they know what is going on.

Whether the stock market has gone up or down, they always have an explanation. We've been conditioned to expect this from them.

It is human nature to make coherent stories out of what we see happening around us. We crave the simple narrative of cause-and-effect.

So when the market drops on the same day that high unemployment figures are released, we link the two things together. We don't, however, make the same connection when the market goes up on the day that even worse unemployment figures are put out a month later. We instead attribute this to something else.Blog 1080x1080 (1)

The need for order

The author of The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable, Nassim Taleb, calls this the narrative fallacy. It is our natural impulse to assign reasons for everything that happens, even when the evidence is flimsy.

It is one of the ways in which we make sense of the world. Since we are constantly faced with so much information, we have to put it in some sort of order to be able to process it. The easiest way to do that is to see a cause for every effect.

In simple matters, this is important and often critical. If your foot is burning because you have put it too close to the fire, then it is worthwhile being able to understand that.

In complex matters, however, the accuracy of this approach is far less perfect. This is because there is often far more going on that we can see on a superficial level, and random chance plays a much bigger role in the world than we like to admit.

 Understanding the market

This is certainly the case with stock markets, which are highly complex systems. There are always many competing forces at play. Even when prices are falling sharply, for instance, there still have to be two parties for any trade to take place.

The people who are desperate to sell their shares have to be selling to somebody. Logically, this must mean that any one-dimensional rationale for anything that happens in the market is an over-simplification.

The investors who are selling must have different motivations than those who are buying. That is, in essence, what makes a market work.

Getting lucky

The human mind also revolts against the idea that chance and luck play a huge part in how the world works. Take Warren Buffett for example. He is widely viewed as one of the most successful investors of the modern era. Many very intelligent people can make extremely persuasive arguments about why this is the case — how his brilliant investment process explains his ultimate success.

However, a sober assessment of Buffett's career would reveal that his approach was not particularly remarkable. It certainly wasn't revolutionary. Buffett himself has said that you don't have to be a genius to be a good investor. Mostly he relied on the ideas of others that came before him.

Without diminishing Buffett's achievements, there were also any number of things that might have disrupted his investment. There were any number of times that bad luck could have derailed his path, but didn't.

There is no question that Buffett is extremely astute, but he has also been exceptionally lucky. Consider that if there is a normal distribution of investing success, it is inevitable that someone would have to be as successful as Buffett.

The important question, however, is whether you could have known when he started out that that individual was going to be him?

It's an illusion

The pioneering behavioral scientist Daniel Kahneman writes that this is really the key. When looking back over Buffett's career with the advantage of hindsight, it might appear that his success was inevitable. However, Kahneman writes that:

“The ultimate test of an explanation is whether it would have made the event predictable in advance.”

Nobody, including Buffett himself, could have foreseen 40 years ago, that he would be who he is today. The simple fact that his investment process is public knowledge and many people have followed it without anywhere near the same level of success emphasizes how true this is.

This, notes Kahneman, highlights the 'illusion of understanding' – our predisposition to build stories from the information available to us. And the better the story is, the more likely we are to believe it.

Buffett's career makes for a great story. But it becomes a lot less appealing if we emphasize his luck, rather than his skill. 

Looking back, looking ahead

The real danger of the "illusion of understanding", however, is that it doesn't just shape our view of the past. As Kahneman writes:

“The core of the illusion is that we believe we understand the past, which implies that the future should also be knowable.”

In other words, because we believe that we are able to assign reasons to everything that happened in the markets yesterday and the day before, we also believe we are able to predict what they will do tomorrow. In other words, we overestimate our ability, and the ability of "experts" to make accurate forecasts.

However, as Kahneman reminds us, the world is unpredictable. Many studies have shown that the ability of even leading experts to make accurate forecasts about anything is extremely poor.

This is worth remembering the next time any expert insists that a market is going to perform a certain way, or there is a particular investment outcome is certain. Even if they have a good story to go with their assessment, there is really no way of knowing if they are going to be right. And there's about an even chance that they won't be.

Source: Regis Media

Was Warren Buffett's success predictable?

Being RiskSmart

WealthFactor Review & Update: March 2021

Behavior: Fear

Investing Essentials: The Different Asset Classes

Interview: How much is enough?

We're not as good at investing as we think we are...

WealthFactor Review & Update: February 2021

Rethinking the value of wealth services

You'd Be Amazed at How Superstitious Investors Are

Interview: Risk Capacity

WealthFactor Review & Update: January 2021

What is evidence-based investing?

WealthFactor Review & Update: December 2020

"Don't just do something. Stand there!"

Interview: Does the financial media help or hurt?

Digital Wealth Management - Launch Announcement

Letting fear lead investment decisions can be costly

WealthFactor Review & Update: November 2020

Not all Advisors are Equal

Successful Investing Is Dull

Complexity Adds to Cost and Risk

WealthFactor October 2020 Review

Reducing market volatility through diversification

Taking a RiskSmart efficiency centric approach to investing.

It’s important to keep the link between wealth and happiness in mind.

September 2020 Review Replay

Preparing for your work-optional stage isn't just financial

August 2020 Review Replay

Webinar Replay: Introduction to Direct Indexing

Using Options for Income

Behavioral Investing Mistakes: Chasing Trends

July 2020 Review Replay

Emotional Investing Mistakes: Attention Span

Retail Investor Rises Again

Emotional Investing Mistakes: Regret

Perspective on Recessions

June 2020 Review Replay

Be Ready for Declines

There is always a reason not to invest

RiskSmart Webinar Replay

Don't work with professionals in the mirage building business.

Your Financial Advisor Has Too Many Clients

May 2020 Review Replay

Be Skeptical of the Investment Media

Beware of Overconfidence Bias

11 Ways Wall Street Gets Paid

Webinar Replay: An Introduction to Direct Indexing

What’s your number?

Refocus: What’s Wall Street Selling Today?

Do You Have a Plan for Getting Punched in the Face?

Financial Planning Matters. But...

WealthFactor April 2020 Review

Refocus 5-8-2020

2020 Berkshire Shareholder Meeting Key Takeaways

Why High Fees Hurt So Much

Refocus 5-1-2020

Introduction to Direct Indexing

Webinar: A Guide to RiskSmart Investing

Refocus 4-24-2020

Overview: PortfolioSmart

Overview: TaxSmart

Overview: FeeSmart

Overview: RiskSmart Investing

Webinar: The Critical Importance of an Investment Plan

Maximizing Opportunity with an Investment Plan - Part 3

The Critical Importance of having an Investment Plan Part #2:

Its time to turn off CNBC and create a plan.

1st Quarter 2020 Review Webinar Review

Why are you paying more and increasing your risk?

High Fees Are Hurting Your Investment Portfolio More Than the Coronavirus.

Pandemic Investing in 3 Parts: How to Navigate the Current Situation.

Four Behaviors Successful Investors Avoid

Are One of the Investors Who Underperform Passive Investing

Do You Invest With Your Emotions?

How should you invest?

Are You Paying Too Much For Investment Advice?

Have Questions? Do You Like Coffee?

Should You Use Funds or Stocks In Your Portfolio?

Commentary: Passive Investing Trends

Review & React: Goldman Sachs Fee Schedule!

Coffee Talk - Open Investment Q & A

Review & React: A Morgan Stanley Investment Proposal

RiskSmart Investing: Portfolio Efficiency

2019 Market and Investor Insights

RiskSmart Investing with WealthFactor

RiskSmart Investing with WealthFactor

Thank you to the Lake Oswego Review

New Addition to the WealthFactor Team

Quarterly Investor Insights

Sample - How To Post

Welcome to WealthFactor

Fed Intervenes in Banking Rate

Now You Can Blog from Everywhere!

Does your investment professional have history?

1st Quarter 2019 Insights

Keys To Investing Success

Tax-Smart Investors Avoid Mutual Funds

2018 Year-End Market Insights

Avoid Premium Prices for Commodity Services

2018 Mid-Year Market Insights

Ask your Adviser for a Discount

Index Investing Enhanced